Within Colorado Cryptids
When Colorado Wildlife Becomes a Monster
Bears, mountain lions, raccoons and poor night footage can turn real Colorado animals into convincing monster stories.
On this page
- Bears, cats and odd silhouettes
- The Pueblo mystery creature story
- How archives and videos spread scares
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
Colorado’s “monster” scares often begin with a real animal seen under bad conditions: a bear half-lit by a porch lamp, a mountain lion moving low through scrub, a raccoon altered by mange, or a bobcat briefly mistaken for something rarer. That does not make the stories worthless. It makes them more interesting. Colorado has genuine large predators, nocturnal urban wildlife, steep terrain, dark timber, and a media culture that can turn a few seconds of footage into a statewide guessing game. The useful question is not simply “was it real?” but “which real animal, disease, angle, behaviour or archive pathway made it look unreal?” Colorado Parks and Wildlife lists black bears, mountain lions and raccoons as ordinary parts of the state’s wildlife picture, while recent Pueblo coverage shows how quickly a sick-looking backyard animal can be discussed as a raccoon, wolverine, badger, chupacabra or unknown creature.[state.co.us]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Black Bearlorado Parks and Wildlife Black Bear
Why Colorado turns wildlife into monsters
Colorado is unusually good at producing “almost-seen” animals. The same habitats that make the state appealing for hiking, camping, rail tourism and mountain-town living also create the conditions for partial sightings: ridgelines, ravines, dense foothill vegetation, snow glare, porch cameras, headlamps, and long distances across open slopes. A figure on a hillside or a shape at a rubbish bin does not arrive as a neat field-guide image. It arrives as movement, size, posture and surprise.
That matters because recognition is usually comparative. A witness does not identify an animal from every feature at once; they match what they saw to a mental library. When the match is incomplete, the mind fills the gap. A raccoon without its normal fluffy outline may no longer look like a raccoon. A bear standing briefly on its hind legs may seem too human-shaped. A mountain lion glimpsed at night may become a “black panther” or “giant cat”, even when lighting has swallowed the tawny colour. The Nature Conservancy’s guide to commonly misidentified mammals makes this broader point plainly: North American wildlife is frequently misread when distance, expectation and similar-looking species get involved.[Cool Green Science]blog.nature.orgCool Green Science A Field Guide to Commonly Misidentified MammalsCool Green Science A Field Guide to Commonly Misidentified Mammals
Colorado adds one more ingredient: human-wildlife overlap. CPW says raccoons are common throughout Colorado and are familiar nocturnal animals even in human-dense areas; it also notes that black bears can change their habits after finding human food and that most bear conflicts trace back to rubbish, pet food, bird seed or other attractants. In monster-lore terms, that means many “creature” encounters happen not in deep wilderness but on porches, roads, alleys, campsites and bins, where people have cameras ready and animals are already behaving in ways that feel bold or unnatural.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.usOpen source on state.co.us.
Bears, cats and odd silhouettes
A misidentification does not require ignorance. It often requires only a bad view of a real animal doing something slightly unexpected. Colorado’s big mammals are particularly good at generating that effect because they are large enough to frighten people, common enough to be encountered, and flexible enough in movement to look strange for a few seconds.
Black bears are the classic shape-shifters of Colorado wildlife scares. They can raid bins, enter settled areas, stand upright, climb, investigate porches and move surprisingly quietly for their size. CPW describes black bears as animals whose behaviour can shift after even one successful human-food reward, and its “Living with Bears” advice links most conflicts to easy food sources such as rubbish, pet food and bird seed. A bear in daylight may be obvious; a bear caught by a night camera beside a garage can become a bulky, hunched, half-human silhouette.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Black Bearlorado Parks and Wildlife Black Bear
Mountain lions create a different kind of scare. CPW says lions mainly live west of I-25 and in parts of south-east Colorado, and that within Colorado they are most abundant in foothills, canyons and mesa country. Those are exactly the kinds of places where sightings may be brief: a long tail disappearing into brush, eye-shine above a trail, a low body crossing a road at dusk. Colorado also has real, if rare, mountain lion danger, so “large cat” stories carry emotional weight even when a particular sighting is uncertain.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.usOpen source on state.co.us.
Bobcats and lynx show how even experienced outdoor observers can struggle with similar animals. CPW’s lynx page says the lynx is easily confused with its more common and widespread relative, the bobcat, and points to details such as tail tip, ear tufts, fur colour and hind-foot size. That kind of distinction is hard enough in a clear photograph. In a fleeting trail-cam clip or roadside sighting, it becomes a recipe for “mystery cat” talk.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Lynxlorado Parks and Wildlife Lynx
Raccoons, foxes and coyotes with mange are the most monster-like small animals because disease changes the outline. CPW explains that sarcoptic mange causes hair loss, severe skin irritation and weight loss, and says coyotes and foxes are most commonly affected in Colorado, though other species can also be affected. A hairless or patchy animal loses the very features that make it familiar: the fox’s plush tail, the raccoon’s rounded body, the coyote’s normal coat. What remains may look raw-skinned, long-limbed and oddly prehistoric.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Disease Exposurelorado Parks and Wildlife Disease Exposure
The Pueblo mystery creature story
The clearest modern Colorado example is the Pueblo mystery creature reported in April 2025. Local and syndicated coverage described a strange small animal filmed outside a home in Pueblo, with online guesses ranging from raccoon and badger to wolverine, cryptid and chupacabra. KOAA reported that Janay Lynn had seen the animal more than once and said it hissed at her; Colorado Parks and Wildlife told the station the animal might be a raccoon with mange, though it could not be identified with complete certainty from the footage. CPW’s reasoning was practical rather than dramatic: the animal’s use of its front paws and its size suggested raccoon.[koaa.com]koaa.comit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in coloradoit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in colorado
That case is useful because it shows the whole mechanism in miniature. The animal appeared close to a home. It was seen at night and around food left out for stray cats. It looked unwell or abnormal. The witness had a strong sense that it did not match ordinary raccoons she had seen before. News anchors and social media viewers then supplied a menu of possibilities, some mundane and some folkloric. Within a few days, the “creepy critter” had travelled through local television, wire-style rewrites, odd-news coverage and national tabloids.[koaa.com]koaa.comit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in coloradoit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in colorado
The raccoon-with-mange explanation did not end the story because misidentification stories are rarely settled by plausibility alone. The footage was not a captured specimen. CPW was careful rather than absolute. The witness disagreed with the raccoon idea. The animal’s appearance was genuinely unsettling. That combination leaves room for argument, and argument is what keeps a monster scare alive online. The Pueblo creature became memorable not because it proved an unknown animal, but because it sat in the uncomfortable middle ground between “obviously a raccoon” and “obviously impossible”.[KOAA News 5]koaa.comit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in coloradoit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in colorado
The chupacabra label also travelled well because it already has a modern North American pattern. In the United States, many alleged chupacabra cases have centred on hairless or diseased canids, especially coyotes with mange. Colorado’s Pueblo story fitted that visual grammar even though CPW leaned towards raccoon rather than coyote. Once viewers saw a gaunt, patchy, unfamiliar animal at night, the folklore slot was ready.[Down To Earth]downtoearth.org.inDown To Earth Is the Chupacabra a Mangy Coyote or Raccoon? TexasDown To Earth Is the Chupacabra a Mangy Coyote or Raccoon? Texas
How archives and videos spread scares
Colorado monster stories do not spread in only one way. Older stories often moved through newspapers, local columns, hunting reports and tall tales. Newer ones move through doorbell cameras, Facebook posts, TikTok-style clips, local TV segments and odd-news syndication. The difference is speed. A nineteenth- or twentieth-century “strange beast” item might circulate through print and then be rediscovered years later. A modern porch video can become a multi-state curiosity before anyone has a clear identification.
The archive side matters because Colorado has a particularly searchable newspaper record. The Colorado Historic Newspapers Collection says it includes more than 8 million digitised pages from over 1,000 Colorado newspaper titles, published from 1859 to 2025. For cryptid research, that is both a gift and a trap. It helps readers find old reports of “monstrous” animals, mountain lion scares, bear incidents and comic tall tales. But old newspaper language often exaggerated danger, borrowed stock phrases, or presented campfire humour as newsy anecdote.[coloradohistoricnewspapers.org]coloradohistoricnewspapers.orgOpen source on coloradohistoricnewspapers.org.
Modern video has the opposite problem: it looks direct, but often supplies too little information. The 2023 Durango-Silverton train “Bigfoot” clip is a useful adjacent example of the same visual problem, even though it is not a simple wildlife case. Passengers filmed a distant dark figure on a hillside near Silverton, and coverage noted that the clip was grainy enough to support competing guesses: Sasquatch, hunter, costume, prank or publicity stunt. Outside’s account captured the core problem: the video was interesting precisely because it was too opaque to settle the matter.[Outside Online]outsideonline.comOutside Online Colorado's Recent Sasquatch Sighting Is Probably a PrankOutside Online Colorado's Recent Sasquatch Sighting Is Probably a Prank
The same uncertainty drives smaller wildlife scares. A doorbell camera flattens depth. Infrared changes colour. Compression blurs fur and limbs. A frightened caption primes viewers before they look. Social comments then create a crowd-sourced identification game where confident wrong answers can spread as quickly as cautious correct ones. In Colorado, where real bears, cats, coyotes, foxes, raccoons and bobcats may all appear near people, the “monster” is often not an invented animal but a real one stripped of context.
Why “misidentified” does not mean “nothing happened”
Calling a Colorado monster scare a probable misidentification can sound dismissive, but it should not. Something usually did happen. Someone saw an animal. The animal may have been sick, unusually bold, poorly lit, partly hidden, moving oddly or simply unfamiliar to the witness. The interesting work is to separate the sighting from the interpretation.
A useful Colorado test is to ask four questions:
- Was the animal behaving around food, rubbish, pets or buildings? If so, bear, raccoon, fox, coyote or other urban-edge wildlife should be considered before anything exotic. CPW repeatedly highlights food attractants as a driver of bear conflict, and raccoons are specifically described as common nocturnal animals in human-dense places.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.usOpen source on state.co.us.
- Did the animal look hairless, raw, thin or oddly long-limbed? Mange can radically change the shape of foxes, coyotes and other mammals, making them look like “wrong” versions of themselves.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Disease Exposurelorado Parks and Wildlife Disease Exposure
- Was it a brief night sighting or a compressed video? Poor footage turns normal proportions into puzzles and encourages viewers to over-read posture, eye-shine and shadow. The Pueblo and Durango-Silverton cases both show how uncertainty increases when the image is dramatic but not diagnostic.[KOAA News 5]koaa.comit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in coloradoit was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in colorado
- Is the proposed creature rarer than the ordinary alternative? A bobcat is a more likely starting point than a lynx in many Colorado “mystery cat” discussions, and CPW explicitly warns that the two are easily confused.[Colorado Parks and Wildlife]cpw.state.co.uslorado Parks and Wildlife Lynxlorado Parks and Wildlife Lynx
This approach keeps the fun without throwing away judgement. A report can be sincere and still mistaken. A video can be real and still not show a monster. A witness can know local wildlife well and still be thrown by disease, lighting or an unusual angle. In fact, those are often the cases that become most persuasive, because the animal is strange enough to unsettle the witness but ordinary enough to leave no spectacular evidence behind.
The Colorado pattern
Misidentified wildlife sits at the practical centre of Colorado monster lore. The state has famous playful legends and Bigfoot traditions, but many smaller scares are powered by ordinary animals crossing the boundary between wild and domestic space. Bears come to bins. Raccoons investigate porches. Mountain lions move through foothills and canyons. Bobcats and lynx confuse even careful observers. Mange turns familiar mammals into raw, unfamiliar shapes. Phones and security cameras preserve the moment, but not always the context.
That pattern also explains why the stories keep changing. In older newspapers, a large cat or bear might become a “monster” through dramatic prose. In modern Pueblo-style scares, the creature becomes a mystery through shareable video and comment-thread speculation. The underlying mechanism is similar: Colorado gives people real wildlife, partial views and enough wilderness atmosphere to make the ordinary feel uncanny.
The most grounded reading is not that every Colorado monster is “just” an animal, nor that every strange clip hides an undiscovered species. It is that Colorado’s real animals already have enough size, stealth, illness, boldness and bad-light weirdness to create convincing monster stories. That is why the best sceptical explanation is not boring. It puts the creature back into the landscape: not as proof of a cryptid, but as a glimpse of how wild the familiar can look when Colorado catches it at the wrong angle.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Endnotes
1.
Source: koaa.com
Title: it was also hissing at me creepy critter spotted in colorado
Link:https://www.koaa.com/news/covering-colorado/it-was-also-hissing-at-me-creepy-critter-spotted-in-colorado
2.
Source: blog.nature.org
Title: Cool Green Science A Field Guide to Commonly Misidentified Mammals
Link:https://blog.nature.org/2019/08/20/a-field-guide-to-commonly-misidentified-mammals/
Published: August 20, 2019
3.
Source: fox10tv.com
Title: what is that creepy unknown critter caught camera
Link:https://www.fox10tv.com/2025/04/08/what-is-that-creepy-unknown-critter-caught-camera/
4.
Source: people.com
Link:https://people.com/spooky-colorado-mystery-animal-sighting-baffles-news-anchors-11715886
5.
Source: coloradohistoricnewspapers.org
Link:https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/
6.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/i.love.dogs.in/posts/mysterious-animal-in-colorado-identified-by-reddit-users-animal-reveal/1438539708302289/
7.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/1399834230537724/posts/1902465786941230/
8.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/WSMVTV/posts/a-woman-in-pueblo-colorado-captured-footage-of-an-unknown-animal-stealing-a-snac/1119936463496163/
9.
Source: facebook.com
Title: people are positing a strange creature caught on camera in colorado could be a r
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KNOE8News/posts/people-are-positing-a-strange-creature-caught-on-camera-in-colorado-could-be-a-r/1067470885416842/
10.
Source: facebook.com
Title: colorado saw a slight increase in conflicts between humans and black bears last
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KOAA/posts/colorado-saw-a-slight-increase-in-conflicts-between-humans-and-black-bears-last-/1350500210450662/
11.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/BestColoradoPhotography/posts/2442031082635893/
12.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/i.love.dogs.in/posts/mysterious-animal-in-colorado-identified-by-reddit-users-animal-reveal/1365478438941750/
13.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/MontanaFWP/posts/are-you-looking-at-a-lynx-or-a-bobcat-on-todays-wildlife-wednesday-corie-explain/3851057191604104/
14.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KOLDNews/posts/what-is-this-it-is-the-mythical-chupacabra-or-simply-a-coyote-with-mange-jeff-sa/2298623590244304/
15.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/CoParksWildlife/posts/hey-hey-hey-this-weekend-dont-plan-on-sharing-your-pic-a-nic-basket-colorados-be/1471028311730928/
16.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KOAA/posts/creepy-critter-in-pueblo-while-colorado-parks-and-wildlife-is-not-quite-sure-wha/1084436840390335/
17.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KMVTNews11/posts/a-strange-unknown-creature-was-caught-on-camera-in-pueblo-colorado/1240211614787854/
18.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/safariclubintl/posts/when-reports-came-in-of-an-old-monstrous-mountain-lion-wreaking-mortal-havoc-on-/567020748805754/
19.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/FoxWeather/videos/predator-peril-officers-from-the-clear-creek-county-sheriffs-office-rescued-two-/1356547252948023/
20.
Source: facebook.com
Title: on this day 120 years ago a real newspaper that still exists today published a s
Link:https://www.facebook.com/cbschicago/posts/on-this-day-120-years-ago-a-real-newspaper-that-still-exists-today-published-a-s/1503410371153171/
21.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/270764112473385/posts/861041746778949/
22.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/nickmolleproductions/videos/do-estes-right-mountain-lions/909342521515313/
23.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/InmobiliariaKP/posts/deadly-lions-bite-a-savage-boy-transforms-into-a-predator-after-surviving/1358026903004230/
24.
Source: facebook.com
Title: a woman claims to have captured new photos and videos of bigfoot on camera durin
Link:https://www.facebook.com/KMVTNews11/posts/a-woman-claims-to-have-captured-new-photos-and-videos-of-bigfoot-on-camera-durin/834325915376428/
25.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/9NewsQueensland/posts/one-hairy-sighting-or-just-a-hoax-passengers-on-a-colorado-train-believe-theyve-/723176436522208/
26.
Source: coloradohistoricnewspapers.org
Link:https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=RMD18930402-01.2.253
27.
Source: coloradohistoricnewspapers.org
Link:https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=RMW19010214-01.2.200
28.
Source: coloradohistoricnewspapers.org
Link:https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=RMD19741208-01.2.346
29.
Source: coloradohistoricnewspapers.org
Link:https://www.coloradohistoricnewspapers.org/?a=d&d=ETG19250320-01.2.12
30.
Source: durango.org
Title: san juans squatchin ultimate bigfoot guide
Link:https://www.durango.org/blog/post/san-juans-squatchin-ultimate-bigfoot-guide/
31.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: lorado Parks and Wildlife Black Bear
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/species/black-bear
Published: December 12, 2023
32.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/species/mountain-lion
33.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/species/raccoon
34.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/living-bears
35.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: lorado Parks and Wildlife Mountain Lion
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/activities/hunting/big-game/hunting-mountain-lion/mountain-lion-conservation-and-management
36.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: lorado Parks and Wildlife Lynx
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/species/lynx
Published: December 12, 2023
37.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: lorado Parks and Wildlife Disease Exposure
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/disease-exposure
Published: January 8, 2024
38.
Source: nypost.com
Link:https://nypost.com/2025/04/10/lifestyle/mystery-chupacabra-like-creature-shows-up-in-freaky-footage/
Source snippet
Online commentators and even wildlife officials have speculated its origins, with guesses ranging from a rabid wolverine to a mangy racco...
39.
Source: downtoearth.org.in
Title: Down To Earth Is the Chupacabra a Mangy Coyote or Raccoon? Texas
Link:https://www.downtoearth.org.in/wildlife-biodiversity/is-the-cryptid-chupacabra-of-the-americas-actually-a-coyote-or-raccoon-with-mange
Published: October 17, 2024
40.
Source: outsideonline.com
Title: Outside Online Colorado’s Recent Sasquatch Sighting Is Probably a Prank
Link:https://www.outsideonline.com/outdoor-adventure/exploration-survival/bigfoot-sighting-durango-colorado/
Published: October 18, 2023
41.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/mammals-research
42.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/sites/default/files/dam/yhac5g6gse/item.25_draft_eastslopemountainlionmanagementplanwithappendices.pdf
43.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/species-profiles
44.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: L19DAUPlan11 2004
Link:https://www.cpw.state.co.us/Documents/Hunting/MountainLion/DAU/L19DAUPlan11-2004.pdf
45.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: item.19a hsus petition materials.and.march.12.letter
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/sites/default/files/dam/souzcgcov3/item.19a-hsus-petition-materials.and.march.12.letter.pdf
46.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/sites/default/files/dam/gudy1td04t/item.16_draft_castlewood_canyon_state_park_management_plan.pdf
47.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: contact us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/contact-us
48.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/sites/default/files/dam/xbpbmjvd4s/22.a_executivesummary_eastslopemountainlionplan_finaldraft_nov2024.pdf
49.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/living-wildlife
50.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/
51.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Title: state.co.us SW A Finder
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/swa-finder
52.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/state-parks/fishers-peak-state-park
53.
Source: cpw.state.co.us
Link:https://cpw.state.co.us/lynx-sighting-form-id
Additional References
54.
Source: newsweek.com
Title: colorado couple spots bigfoot 1833819
Link:https://www.newsweek.com/colorado-couple-spots-bigfoot-1833819
55.
Source: cbsnews.com
Title: maryland chupacabra idd as fox with mange
Link:https://www.cbsnews.com/news/maryland-chupacabra-idd-as-fox-with-mange/
56.
Source: cowboystatedaily.com
Title: cheyenne couple reportedly spots bigfoot from train media goes bonkers
Link:https://cowboystatedaily.com/2023/10/11/cheyenne-couple-reportedly-spots-bigfoot-from-train-media-goes-bonkers/
57.
Source: denver7.com
Link:https://www.denver7.com/news/environment/colorado-saw-a-5-increase-in-human-bear-conflicts-compared-to-2024-with-unsecured-trash-still-a-big-problem
58.
Source: denvergazette.com
Link:https://www.denvergazette.com/2025/04/08/watch-creepy-creature-turns-heads-in-colorado-with-experts-not-100-sure-of-species/
59.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/reel/DNOxC7mM7e1/
60.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/reel/DTBE3d4iaqN/?hl=en
61.
Source: instagram.com
Link:https://www.instagram.com/reel/DUYrBlFEzum/?hl=en
62.
Source: kctv5.com
Title: what is that creepy unknown critter caught camera
Link:https://www.kctv5.com/2025/04/08/what-is-that-creepy-unknown-critter-caught-camera/
63.
Source: kktv.com
Title: creepy creature caught camera pueblo
Link:https://www.kktv.com/video/2025/04/07/creepy-creature-caught-camera-pueblo/
Topic Tree