Within Arizona Monsters
What Was Tombstone's Winged Monster?
A strange 1890 Tombstone report helped turn a winged desert creature into one of Arizona's most replayed monster tales.
On this page
- The 1890 Tombstone newspaper report
- How the story became a thunderbird legend
- Pterosaurs, tall tales and frontier press habits
Page outline Jump by section
Introduction
The Tombstone Thunderbird is not a confirmed monster from the Arizona desert. It is a newspaper mystery: a short item printed in the Tombstone Epitaph on 26 April 1890, later retold as if two ranchers had killed a gigantic flying creature somewhere between the Whetstone and Huachuca mountains. The original report described a winged animal with an alligator-like body, a long tail and enormous leathery wings, but it named no ranchers, produced no specimen, and led to no known follow-up investigation. The legend matters because it shows how an odd frontier newspaper item became one of Arizona’s most replayed cryptid tales: part pterosaur fantasy, part “lost photograph” obsession, part Old West tall story. The strongest evidence is that the article existed; the weakest part is nearly everything that later made the story famous.[azlibrary.gov]azmemory.azlibrary.govAZ MemoryTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26 - Arizona Memory ProjectTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26; City or TownTombstone; CountyCochise Coun…
The 1890 Tombstone newspaper report
The core source is the 26 April 1890 issue of the Tombstone Epitaph, preserved in the Arizona Memory Project and the Library of Congress newspaper record. The relevant item appeared under the headline “Found on the Desert” and described “a strange winged monster” supposedly discovered and killed on the Huachuca Desert. The Library of Congress text places the creature between the Whetstone and Huachuca mountains, a real south-eastern Arizona landscape of basins, ranges and ranching routes rather than an invented fantasy setting.[AZ Memory]azmemory.azlibrary.govAZ MemoryTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26 - Arizona Memory ProjectTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26; City or TownTombstone; CountyCochise Coun…
The report’s creature is strange even before later retellings get involved. It was said to resemble a huge alligator with a very long tail and a huge pair of wings. Two ranchers, returning from the Huachucas, allegedly found it exhausted and able to fly only a short distance. They pursued it on horseback, shot it, examined it, and measured it. Later summaries of the article give the familiar astonishing figures: a body about 92 feet long, wings about 160 feet from tip to tip, an eight-foot head, and eyes supposedly as large as dinner plates.[creationtales.com]creationtales.com65 article from the april 26 1890 tombstone epitaph65 article from the april 26 1890 tombstone epitaph
Those measurements are the first major warning sign. Arizona has large birds, but nothing remotely close to a 160-foot wingspan. The California condor, North America’s largest flying land bird, has a wingspan of about 9.5 feet; Arizona Game and Fish says condors in the state use thermal updrafts, may travel long distances, and are associated today with northern Arizona’s Vermilion Cliffs reintroduction area. The National Park Service similarly gives the condor’s wingspan as up to 9.5 feet and notes that it is at least two feet larger than the next largest bird in the region, the golden eagle.[Arizona Game & Fish Department]azgfd.comArizona Game & Fish Department California CondorArizona Game & Fish Department California Condor
That comparison does not prove the Tombstone story was intentionally fake, but it does show the scale of the problem. Even if a rancher, reporter or later reader mistook a large soaring bird for something extraordinary, the published dimensions belong to the world of newspaper marvels rather than zoology. A condor, vulture or eagle can look immense in desert light, especially when seen overhead or at a distance. It cannot become a creature longer than a railway carriage and wider than a modern airliner.
How the story became a thunderbird legend
The original article did not need the word “thunderbird” to become thunderbird folklore. It had all the ingredients: a desert setting, armed frontier men, a dead impossible animal, measurements too large to dismiss quietly, and a newspaper name already loaded with Old West atmosphere. Tombstone was not just any Arizona town in later public memory. It was the town of the O.K. Corral, silver mining, gunfight tourism and frontier mythmaking. A strange item from that paper was easy to repackage as an Arizona monster legend.
The story changed most dramatically when the alleged “lost thunderbird photograph” entered the tradition. Many modern tellings claim that a photograph once showed a huge dead bird or pterosaur-like animal nailed to a barn or wall, with men standing beside it for scale. The problem is that the 1890 article did not include such a photograph, and serious searches have not produced a verified copy. Karl Shuker, a long-time cryptozoology writer who has written extensively on the missing-photo story, notes that many people claim to have seen the image in old magazines, but no one has produced the supposed original, and the Tombstone Epitaph archives do not contain it.[ShukerNature]karlshuker.blogspot.comShukerNatureShukerNature: SEEKING THE MISSING THUNDERBIRD PHOTOGRAPH - ONE OF CRYPTOZOOLOGY'S MOST TANTALISING UNSOLVED CASES…
This is why the Tombstone Thunderbird has two overlapping mysteries. The first is the 1890 newspaper item: why was it printed, and was it meant as a joke, hoax, filler item, exaggerated report or straight-faced marvel? The second is the later memory mystery: why do so many people think they remember a photograph that has not been found? Those two mysteries are often fused in popular retellings, but they should be kept separate. The article is real. The famous photograph remains unverified.
One reason the photo legend is so persistent is that it is visually simple. A giant bird or reptile stretched across a barn wall, with men lined up underneath it, is easy to imagine and easy to misremember. Shuker has argued that “lookalike” images may have helped create false memories, especially old photographs of large birds with wings outstretched and people nearby. He points in particular to a marabou stork image reproduced in widely circulated books, including a 1970s edition of the Guinness Book of Records, as the kind of picture that could be mentally blended with the Tombstone tale.[ShukerNature]karlshuker.blogspot.comShukerNatureShukerNature: SEEKING THE MISSING THUNDERBIRD PHOTOGRAPH - ONE OF CRYPTOZOOLOGY'S MOST TANTALISING UNSOLVED CASES…
The legend also gained strength from twentieth-century cryptozoology and Fortean writing. Writers and investigators such as Ivan T. Sanderson and John Keel became attached to versions of the missing-photo story, and later researchers debated whether they had seen, handled, heard about or merely described an image. A 2026 MonsterTalk episode summarised the current sceptical direction neatly: serious researchers have increasingly converged on a false-memory explanation, while debates about the photo continue.[MonsterTalk]monstertalk.orgMonster Talk S05E14Monster Talk S05E14
Pterosaurs, tall tales and frontier press habits
The pterosaur reading is easy to understand. A huge alligator-like body, long tail and leathery wings sound less like a bird than a nineteenth-century popular image of a flying reptile. Pterosaurs were already known to science by 1890, and prehistoric animals had entered popular imagination through museums, newspapers and illustrated curiosities. Retelling the Tombstone creature as a “pterodactyl” made the story more vivid and more marketable.
Yet the pterosaur theory also creates more problems than it solves. A living pterosaur in 1890 Arizona would not be a local oddity; it would be one of the most important biological discoveries in history. The article gives no specimen location, no named witnesses, no rancher identities, no preserved bones, no skin, no scientific inspection and no credible chain of custody. A creature allegedly measured at fantastic size should have produced follow-up notices, rival newspaper coverage, public exhibition, scientific correspondence or at least local argument. The available record instead leaves readers with a single sensational item and a much later folklore afterlife.
Frontier newspapers often printed strange filler, jokes, exaggerated animal stories and marvels from other places. That does not mean every odd item was fake, but it means the form itself needs caution. The Epitaph report reads like a compact curiosity: dramatic, specific enough to be memorable, but vague exactly where verification would matter. “Two ranchers” is not much of a witness list. “Between the Whetstone and Huachuca mountains” gives atmosphere rather than a recoverable site. The measurements create spectacle rather than plausibility.
The creature’s reported size is especially revealing. In folklore, exaggerated scale is often the point. A tall tale works by taking a recognisable natural experience — a startling bird, a strange carcass, a shadow over desert ground — and stretching it beyond ordinary reality. The Tombstone report does that with remarkable efficiency. It does not merely say the animal was large. It makes it impossibly large, then gives measurements that sound factual enough to invite argument.
Why the missing photograph became the bigger mystery
For many readers, the Tombstone Thunderbird is less about the 1890 article than about the photograph they feel they once saw. That is what makes the case unusually modern despite its Old West setting. It behaves like lost media: a rumoured image, vivid descriptions, repeated claims of childhood memory, magazine searches, debunked substitutes and a constant stream of reproductions that muddy the water.
Several fake or unrelated images have circulated as the “real” photograph. Some show pterosaur props or manipulated scenes; others are artistic recreations that later viewers mistake for historical evidence. Shuker has documented hoaxed thunderbird images and noted how easily a new fake can become embedded in online discussions. The Lost Media Wiki likewise treats the Tombstone Thunderbird photograph as a claimed lost cryptid image whose existence remains unconfirmed, and notes that some alleged photographs have been debunked.[ShukerNature]karlshuker.blogspot.comShukerNatureShukerNature: SEEKING THE MISSING THUNDERBIRD PHOTOGRAPH - ONE OF CRYPTOZOOLOGY'S MOST TANTALISING UNSOLVED CASES…
The photo legend also mutated in detail. In some versions, the creature is a giant bird; in others, it is a pterosaur. Sometimes it is nailed to a barn; sometimes propped against a wall; sometimes displayed with cowboys, hunters or soldiers. The supposed wingspan may be 18 feet, 36 feet or much larger, depending on the retelling. Those variations matter because stable details are one thing investigators look for when assessing a tradition. Here, the most memorable details are also the most fluid.[KGUN 9 Tucson News]kgun9.comKGUN 9 Tucson News The Tombstone Thunderbird. Legend or Lie?KGUN 9 Tucson News The Tombstone Thunderbird. Legend or Lie?
The most plausible explanation is not that thousands of people are lying. It is that a powerful image can be assembled from memory fragments: the Tombstone article, magazine illustrations, large-bird photographs, pterosaur artwork, Western imagery, and later internet recreations. Once a person has heard the description, it can feel familiar. That is why the missing photograph is best treated as part of the legend’s afterlife, not as evidence for the 1890 creature.
What the Arizona setting adds to the mystery
The Tombstone Thunderbird belongs specifically to Arizona because the landscape and the newspaper setting do real work in the story. The Whetstone and Huachuca mountains sit in south-eastern Arizona’s borderland country, where open desert basins meet rugged sky-island ranges. That kind of terrain is perfect for a winged-monster tale: huge skies, harsh distances, heat shimmer, carrion birds, ranch travel and long sightlines that can make scale hard to judge.
The local wildlife context also matters. A real large bird in Arizona is not absurd. Condors, vultures, eagles and large water birds can all look impressive under the right conditions, and condors in particular show how the American West genuinely has birds big enough to inspire awe. But the known birds provide a ceiling as well as a starting point. The largest credible native candidate is still measured in feet, not scores of feet.[Arizona Game & Fish Department]azgfd.comArizona Game & Fish Department California CondorArizona Game & Fish Department California Condor
Tombstone itself adds another layer. The town’s public identity has long been tied to frontier performance: lawmen, gunfighters, saloons, newspapers, graveyards and staged memory. The Thunderbird fits that culture neatly because it is a monster story that feels like a Western anecdote. It is not a hidden lake creature or a forest Bigfoot. It is a desert confrontation, settled with rifles, reported in a mining-town paper, and later framed by readers as proof that the Old West contained stranger things than gunfights.
That makes it a useful companion to other Arizona mystery-beast traditions without being the same kind of story. The Mogollon Monster depends on recurring campfire and forest sightings. The Red Ghost overlaps with documented camel history. The Tombstone Thunderbird rests on a single newspaper item and a later missing-photo rumour. Its value is not in the strength of its animal evidence, but in how clearly it shows the machinery of legend-making.
So what was Tombstone’s winged monster?
The safest answer is that Tombstone’s winged monster was almost certainly a newspaper marvel rather than a real unknown animal. The original 1890 article is genuine, but the report gives too little verifiable detail and too much impossible scale to support a biological claim. No named ranchers, no preserved body, no scientific inspection, no confirmed photograph and no reliable follow-up have emerged from the record.
Several explanations remain possible, but they are not equally strong:
- A deliberate tall tale: The simplest reading is that the Epitaph printed a frontier exaggeration or joke in the style of nineteenth-century newspaper curiosities.
- An exaggerated encounter with a real bird: A large vulture, eagle or condor-like bird could have inspired part of the story, but not the published size or reptilian anatomy.
- A carcass or object misdescribed after the fact: The alligator-like body and leathery wings could reflect rumour, misperception or imaginative reporting rather than direct observation.
- A surviving pterosaur: This is the most exciting version, but also the least supported. It would require extraordinary evidence, and the Tombstone case does not provide it.
- A false-memory photo tradition: This best explains the later “I saw the photograph” claims, especially given the absence of a verified image and the presence of plausible lookalike photographs and recreations.[ShukerNature]karlshuker.blogspot.comShukerNatureShukerNature: SEEKING THE MISSING THUNDERBIRD PHOTOGRAPH - ONE OF CRYPTOZOOLOGY'S MOST TANTALISING UNSOLVED CASES…
The enduring appeal of the Tombstone Thunderbird comes from the gap between a real printed item and an unreal creature. There is just enough archive behind it to keep the story from being pure invention, and just enough missing evidence to keep it from becoming history. In Arizona’s cryptid tradition, it is less a monster in the desert than a monster in the newspaper record: a winged shape made from ink, memory and the long shadow of the Old West.
Amazon book picks
Further Reading
Books and field guides related to What Was Tombstone's Winged Monster?. Use these as the next step if you want deeper reading beyond the article.
The United States of Cryptids
Includes regional monster traditions and famous sightings.
eBay marketplace picks
Marketplace Samples
Live-tested eBay searches with available results related to this page.
Endnotes
1.
Source: monstertalk.org
Title: Monster Talk S05E14
Link:https://www.monstertalk.org/s05e14-the-case-of-the-missing-thunderbird-photo/
2.
Source: kgun9.com
Title: KGUN 9 Tucson News The Tombstone Thunderbird. Legend or Lie?
Link:https://www.kgun9.com/entertainment/legend-or-lie/legend-or-lie-tombstone-thunderbird-sighting
3.
Source: newspapers.com
Title: tombstone epitaph winged monster in ariz
Link:https://www.newspapers.com/article/tombstone-epitaph-winged-monster-in-ariz/2995114/
4.
Source: newspapers.com
Link:https://www.newspapers.com/article/tombstone-epitaph-thunderbird-winged-mo/55508809/
5.
Source: azmemory.azlibrary.gov
Link:https://azmemory.azlibrary.gov/nodes/view/141716
Source snippet
AZ MemoryTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26 - Arizona Memory ProjectTombstone Epitaph, 1890-04-26; City or TownTombstone; CountyCochise Coun...
6.
Source: loc.gov
Title: The creat ure was
Link:https://www.loc.gov/resource/sn95060905/1890-04-26/ed-1/?dl=page&q=found+on+the+desert&sp=3&st=text
Source snippet
The Library of CongressImage 3 of Tombstone epitaph (Tombstone, Ariz.), April 26...found on the desert betwetn the Whet stone and Huach...
7.
Source: karlshuker.blogspot.com
Link:https://karlshuker.blogspot.com/2014/11/seeking-missing-thunderbird-photograph.html
Source snippet
ShukerNatureShukerNature: SEEKING THE MISSING THUNDERBIRD PHOTOGRAPH - ONE OF CRYPTOZOOLOGY'S MOST TANTALISING UNSOLVED CASES...
8.
Source: creationtales.com
Title: 65 article from the april 26 1890 tombstone epitaph
Link:https://creationtales.com/blog/65-article-from-the-april-26-1890-tombstone-epitaph.html
9.
Source: dragoonarizona.com
Link:https://www.dragoonarizona.com/dragoon-history-attractions/miscellaneous/dragoon-dragon-the-legend-of
10.
Source: azgfd.com
Title: Arizona Game & Fish Department California Condor
Link:https://www.azgfd.com/species/california-condor-2/
11.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/groups/monstertalkgroupmail/posts/26107572972168177/
12.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/azgfd/photos/which-bird-has-a-wingspan-that-can-reach-the-length-of-a-larger-surfboard-the-ca/949707280521677/
13.
Source: azgfd.com
Title: wild about arizona california condors
Link:https://www.azgfd.com/event/wild-about-arizona-california-condors/
14.
Source: azgfd.com
Title: Wild Kids
Link:https://www.azgfd.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/WildKids_8_raptors.pdf
15.
Source: Wikipedia
Link:https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Condor
16.
Source: nps.gov
Title: california condor
Link:https://www.nps.gov/articles/000/california-condor.htm
17.
Source: karlshuker.blogspot.com
Title: exposing truly batty example of fake
Link:https://karlshuker.blogspot.com/2020/10/exposing-truly-batty-example-of-fake.html
18.
Source: karlshuker.blogspot.com
Link:https://karlshuker.blogspot.com/2014/11/
19.
Source: raptor.umn.edu
Title: california condor
Link:https://raptor.umn.edu/about-raptors/raptors-north-america/california-condor
20.
Source: defenders.org
Title: california condor
Link:https://defenders.org/wildlife/california-condor
21.
Source: shukernature2.rssing.com
Title: comthe curious case of the bottled sea serpent
Link:https://shukernature2.rssing.com/chan-6154386/all_p11.html
Additional References
22.
Source: youtube.com
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rn2p41EN-dw
Source snippet
The UnXplained: Pterodactyl Creature Spotted in 1800s Arizona (Season 4)...
23.
Source: youtube.com
Title: PROOF of the Tombstone Thunderbird
Link:https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Hf6tpIbDLic
Source snippet
They Photographed a Thunderbird in 1890 — The Tombstone Epitaph Printed It...
24.
Source: fws.gov
Link:https://www.fws.gov/species/california-condor-gymnogyps-californianus
25.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/DiscoverTombstoneAZ/posts/discover-tombstone-takes-another-look-at-cryptozoology-the-tombstone-thunderbird/1204617275004062/
26.
Source: rachelcarsoncouncil.org
Link:https://rachelcarsoncouncil.org/big-bigger-biggest/
27.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/martindiesjrstatepark/posts/lets-celebrate-a-species-group-that-never-really-gets-look-at-twice-buzzards-and/1490463423125014/
28.
Source: peregrinefund.org
Link:https://peregrinefund.org/explore-raptors-species/vultures/california-condor
29.
Source: cryptidarchives.fandom.com
Link:https://cryptidarchives.fandom.com/wiki/Tombstone_Epitaph_thunderbird_photograph
30.
Source: facebook.com
Link:https://www.facebook.com/troytayloroddities/photos/the-tombstone-thunderbird-photographon-april-26-1880-the-tombstone-arizona-newsp/122126353988651114/
31.
Source: reddit.com
Link:https://www.reddit.com/r/Cryptozoology/comments/1f60k6w/the_ivan_t_sanderson_files_origin_of_the/
Topic Tree